24/7 Emergency Service Available
Family-Owned & Operated Since 1981
Domino Fuel - Long Island heating oil and HVAC
Suffolk County(631) 779-3196 Nassau County(516) 357-5773
Order Oil OnlineRequest ServiceRequest a Quote
★ Licensed & Insured · Serving Long Island Since 1981

Oil Tank Replacement on Long Island

Replace an aging tank on your terms, before it leaks. We remove the old tank and install a new, leak-resistant one the same day across Suffolk and Nassau, with no interruption to your heat.

Get a Free Quote Today Call (631) 779-3196
Free estimates · Code-compliant work · 24/7 emergency response
★★★★★
At a Glance

Replace an oil tank when it passes 15 years or shows rust, weeping seams, or staining underneath. Domino Fuel removes the old tank and installs a new leak-resistant one, almost always the same day, so your heat is never interrupted.

Licensed & Insured

Fully licensed NY tank contractor

24/7 Emergency

Spill and leak response anytime

Code-Compliant

Suffolk & Nassau permit work

Free Estimates

No-obligation tank quotes

Tank Replacement

Oil Tank Replacement Services on Long Island

If your oil tank is aging but has not yet failed, replacing it on your terms is far cheaper and far less stressful than waiting for a leak. A planned replacement means no emergency, no spill, and no scramble, just a clean swap from your tired old tank to a modern, leak-resistant one.

Domino Fuel makes replacement seamless. We remove the old tank and install a brand-new code-compliant tank, almost always the same day, so your heat is never interrupted. It is the complete project, oil tank removal and oil tank installation together, handled by one licensed local crew that has served Suffolk and Nassau since 1981.

Same-Day ServiceOil tank replacement on Long Island, old tank removed and new tank installed
When to Replace

When to Replace Your Oil Tank

Replacing proactively, before a failure, is the smart, lower-cost move. Here is how to know it is time.

Age and Lifespan

Most above-ground steel tanks last 15 to 20 years. Once a tank passes the 15-year mark, the risk of a leak climbs every season. If yours is in that range and still sound, a planned replacement now avoids an emergency later.

Warning Signs

Surface rust, weeping seams, wet spots or staining beneath the tank, a persistent oil odor, or unusually high oil usage all point to a tank near the end of its life. If your tank is already leaking, do not wait, go straight to leaking oil tank replacement and, if there is any pooled oil, our emergency oil spill cleanup team.

Tank Brands We Carry

Oil Tank Brands We Install on Long Island

Replacement is the perfect time to upgrade to a tank built not to fail. These are the leak-resistant tanks we install across Long Island.

01 / Granby

Granby EcoGard

Granby's premium leak-protection tank. A second steel bottom and a corrosion-resistant interior guard against the rust-through failures that cause most basement leaks, making EcoGard our go-to upgrade for worry-free heating.

02 / Granby

Granby Standard

The dependable, industry-standard residential steel tank. Built to UL specifications and trusted in Long Island basements for decades, the Granby Standard is a cost-effective, reliable replacement on a sound budget.

03 / Roth

Roth Double-Wall

A leak-resistant inner tank inside a galvanized-steel outer shell, the Roth holds 110% of capacity if the inner wall is ever breached. It is lightweight, compact, and backed by a strong manufacturer warranty.

Our Process

Our Same-Day Oil Tank Replacement Process

One visit, one crew, no interruption to your heat.

1. Free Assessment and Quote

We inspect your current tank, recommend the right replacement, and give you a clear written price.

2. Old Tank Removed

We safely pump out and remove your old tank as part of our oil tank removal service, and if the job needs more time we set a temporary oil tank installation so your heat stays on.

3. New Tank Installed and Tested

We complete a code-compliant oil tank installation, connect and test the system, and clean up. Want the full menu of tank services? Visit our oil tank services hub.

Why Replace Your Tank With Domino Fuel

  • Avoid the cost and mess of an emergency leak
  • Same-day removal and installation
  • Leak-resistant Granby and Roth tanks
  • Licensed, insured, code-compliant work
  • Temporary tank available if needed
  • Free, no-obligation written estimate
Choosing a Tank

Selecting the Right Replacement Oil Tank

Replacement is the moment to upgrade to a tank built for the long haul. We help you weigh material, design, and cost.

Tank Materials and Designs

Steel tanks, including Granby, offer proven reliability and strength. Fiberglass and fiberglass-coated tanks are corrosion-resistant and long-lasting, which is why underground tanks are typically fiberglass-coated and carry manufacturer warranties up to 30 years. Double-wall models such as the Granby EcoGard and the Roth add a second layer of protection that prevents leaks and contamination.

Eco-Friendly Options

Modern tanks, often double-walled or with secondary containment, are designed to prevent leaks and last longer. Upgrading to a contemporary, code-compliant tank reduces the chance of a spill and the costly cleanup that follows.

Warranties

Tank Warranties and Longevity

A strong warranty signals a manufacturer's confidence in the product, and protects your investment.

Warranties vary by manufacturer. Many Granby and similar tanks come with extended warranties, some lasting up to 25 years, and underground fiberglass-coated tanks can carry warranties up to 30 years. Proper, certified installation directly influences how long your tank lasts, so we install every tank to code and back our workmanship. Choosing a tank with a solid warranty and a proven track record gives you lasting value and peace of mind.

Cost & Financing

Oil Tank Replacement Cost and Financing

Costs vary with the size, location, and condition of your old tank. Here is a realistic range, plus ways to manage it.

Every tank is different, so we do not quote a flat price. The cost of a replacement depends on the tank you choose, whether the old tank is above-ground or underground, access, and the extent of any soil contamination. We give every homeowner a free, no-obligation price up front with no hidden fees. Call (631) 779-3196 or request a free quote for an exact number for your home.

Factors that influence cost:

  • Size and location of the tank
  • Above-ground versus underground
  • Extent of any soil contamination
  • Disposal fees and post-removal cleanup

Financing can ease the cost. Homeowners may use personal loans, home equity, or programs designed for environmental repairs, and New York State offers aid programs that may provide tax credits toward removing or replacing a residential oil tank. Homeowner's insurance may also cover part of a leak-related replacement, so it is worth checking your policy. Ask us about financing options and zero-down plans on qualifying projects.

Your Options

Choose From 3 Trusted Oil Tanks

Every tank we install is leak-resistant and code-compliant. Here is a simple side-by-side so you can pick the right fit for your home and budget.

Granby Standard steel oil tank
Good Value

Granby Standard

Proven, budget-friendly steel.

  • Rugged single-wall steel construction
  • The trusted 275-gallon size for most basements
  • A dependable, affordable choice
Granby EcoGard double-bottom oil tank
Better

Granby EcoGard

Built-in leak protection.

  • Double-bottom design with built-in leak monitoring
  • 25-year warranty against defects and internal corrosion
  • A smart upgrade for extra peace of mind
Roth double-wall oil tank
Best Protection

Roth Double-Wall

Maximum leak protection.

  • Seamless inner tank inside a galvanized steel outer shell
  • Outer shell holds 110% of the inner tank, plus an optical leak alarm
  • Premium protection and a long service life

Not sure which is right for your home? We will walk you through it and recommend the best fit, free. Get a free estimate.

Brands We Carry

Oil Tank Brands We Install

Your new tank is a leak-resistant, code-compliant model from a trusted manufacturer.

RothGranby

Time to Replace That Aging Tank?

Replace on your schedule, not during an emergency. Get a free same-day replacement quote today.

Get a Free Quote Today Call (631) 779-3196
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the questions Long Island homeowners ask us most.

1When should I replace my oil tank?

Most tanks should be replaced around 15 to 20 years of age, or sooner if you see rust, weeping seams, staining beneath the tank, or rising oil usage. Replacing before a failure is much cheaper than cleaning up after a leak.

2Is replacement the same as removal and installation?

Yes. A replacement is the complete project: we remove your old tank and install a new code-compliant one, almost always in the same visit.

3Will my heat be interrupted during replacement?

Rarely. We typically remove and install the same day, and if a job needs more time we set a temporary tank so your heat stays on throughout.

4What will my new tank be made of?

We install Granby EcoGard, Granby Standard, and Roth double-wall tanks, all modern, leak-resistant designs that far outlast the bare steel tanks of decades past.

5How much does oil tank replacement cost on Long Island?

It depends on the tank you choose, placement, and the condition of the old tank. We provide a free written estimate covering both removal and installation so there are no surprises.

6Do you replace outdoor and underground tanks too?

Yes. We replace basement, outdoor, and underground tanks. Underground projects involve excavation and soil testing, which we explain in your estimate.

7My tank is already leaking, is that still a replacement?

If your tank is actively leaking it is an urgent situation. Start with our leaking oil tank replacement service, and if there is any pooled oil, call right away for emergency spill cleanup.

Call Now Text Us